“Esther
opened the first note on a Tuesday, on a breezy April afternoon in Northern
Virginia. The note—off-white paper, folded twice, addressed in capital letters
to ‘The Jews on Elm Street’—had been slipped into the mailbox underneath
several bills and a Sears, Roebuck catalog….Sliding the rest of the mail under
one arm, Esther opened the note. Inside the note was one thing, just a symbol,
and yet not just a symbol, not to Esther and certainly not to her
grandmother, who had barely escaped the war. Inside the note was a swastika,
intended just for them, the only Jews on Elm Street.”—American lawyer,
journalist, and essayist Anna Stolley Persky, “The Jews on Elm Street,” Ellery
Queen Mystery Magazine, September-October 2024
With all
the things requiring my focus these days, I don’t have the time to take in all
the detection fiction I want to read. But this short story by Anna Stolley Persky called insistently for my attention from its first few paragraphs.
It’s not
just a crime story, but a coming-of-age tale involving 14-year-old Esther,
forced to confront mounting, insidious terror few would believe possible in the
Northern Virginia suburb Cherry Tree. And—especially relevant now—it’s about
the persistence of antisemitism, decades after the US defeated its most
dangerous exponent in World War II, and about the ordinary people—even those,
like Esther’s beloved grandmother Orly, waning in physical strength—called upon
to defend against it again.
The
threatening notes in the initial paragraphs of this short story escalate until
Orly pieces together the clues to determine who was responsible for sending
them. Though it is set in the mid-1980s (there are references to Columbo
reruns and to Murder, She Wrote, “a newer show Orly had started
watching”), it is all too applicable to America in 2025:
“Here,
Orly thought, was a life lesson for Esther. The authorities were not
necessarily there to protect THEM. Here was the lesson she never wanted, but
always needed her granddaughter to understand. Maybe things changed a little.
Certainly, this country was better than others, but eventually it all circled
back to the same idea: They would always be struggling against the same
prejudices, over and over, generation after generation.”
I greatly
enjoyed this, Ms. Persky’s first published fiction—and evidently, I’m far from
the only one. It has been named a finalist for the Robert L. Fish Memorial
Award for Best First Mystery Story, to be given in early May. I look forward to
more work by this fellow Columbo devotee who, like me, believes, as she noted
in this guest post for the “Something Is Going to Happen!” blog, in the
importance of “character-driven” detective novels.